p.enthalabs

iPhone Duo Teardown: The Most Repairable Foldable Has a Huge Screen Problem

Apple’s folding iPhone finally made it to our teardown table. Some owners’ screens didn’t make it through setup.

After fifteen years of patents and rumors, the iPhone Duo is here, and repair shops may not have long to wait for their first customers. Owners are already reporting cracks and bright lines along the fold. Though Apple’s offering replacement units for now, any out-of-warranty screen damage will cost $999. So of course we wanted a closer look at what’s happening underneath.

!Image 1: iPhone Duo accordioned out

First gen hardware teething pains aside, there’s plenty to admire in the iPhone Duo. Apple borrowed some of our favorite repair tricks from ordinary iPhones: batteries that release with electricity, an outer screen that’s pleasantly simple to remove, and lots of components you can reach without dismantling half the phone.

Together, those choices make this the most repairable foldable smartphone we’ve ever taken apart. But that’s definitely _not_ an endorsement of repairing the Duo. Fixing the phone’s inner screen is still going to be a bear.

We took the Duo all the way down to the gears, followed glowing dust into its hinge, and put its crease-hiding nano-texture under the microscope. Here’s what we found.

Video 5

The Crease Has a Very Good Disguise

Every foldable, well, folds. Repeatedly. Materials fatigue with repeated mechanical stress, and over time you’d expect to see evidence in the way of marks, creases, or wrinkles along the fold. It’s a real engineering magic trick to make a folding OLED look flat when it’s fully open, and no foldable phone has solved that problem completely. Not even the Duo, no matter how many Apple fans call it “creaseless.”

Don’t get us wrong. The Duo’s inner display looks remarkably smooth. Its hinge and supporting layers help it open flat, while the matte nano-texture finish scatters reflections across the surface, further concealing any evidence of a crease.

Under our Evident DSX2000 microscope, that finish looks like tiny rounded bumps packed together, a little like bubble wrap. They scatter light, softening the reflections you see on the screen.

!Image 2: Nanotexture with screen lit

The diffusion effect of the nano-texture is obvious when we zoom into the camera cutout: on the left, pixels shining clearly through the smooth, untextured circle in the nano-texture layer. On the right, the pixel grid is fuzzed by the bubble wrap.

When lights reflect off the screen, they bend as they cross the crease. Scattering that reflection helps hide the dip. When we take off the nano-texture layer, lights reflect off the crease not too differently from what we’ve seen in other foldables.

![Image 3: iPhone Duo without the matte layer, crease visible](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/24232211/iPhone-Duo_45a.jpg)![Image 4: Z Fold8, crease visible](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/24232212/iPhone-Duo_45b.jpg)

Here’s the Duo with the nano-texture removed (left), compared to the Z Fold8 (right). Without the bubble wrap disguise, the Duo’s crease is arguably even more visible than the Fold8’s. If for some reason you like the shiny Duo better, fair warning: the surface underneath scratches more easily.

Apple has offered nano-texture on rigid displays before, including the iPad Pro, MacBook Pro, and Pro Display XDR. Here, the surface treatment lives on a flexible polymer cover that can be replaced while keeping the OLED beneath it.

!Image 5: Nanotexture closeup at the edge of camera cutout

Rounded bumps cover the nano-textured surface.

Reviewers famously killed their original Galaxy Fold displays by peeling off what looked like a screen protector. We’re really glad to see that not only will the display still function after removing this cover layer, but Apple actually provides a cover-layer replacement procedure.To be clear, it’s not a simple DIY screen-protector swap. Apple’s procedure calls for specialized fixtures and precise alignment, but being able to replace the outer layer without sacrificing the OLED is still a meaningful improvement.

Cover-layer service costs $49 without AppleCare, or $19 with it. Not too bad, and it’s great that you can refresh a cover layer without having to replace the whole screen.

Replacing the whole screen is where the repair bill starts to look scary. Again, inner-display damage will run $999 without coverage. We’ll sell replacement screens as soon and as affordably as we can, but this is a complicated part and even on its own it won’t be cheap.

And don’t be fooled by how quickly Shahram got that inner screen off in our video: that screen repair will be slow. We estimate a similar repair on the Pixel 10 Pro Fold will take a typical DIYer 3-5 hours. The Duo should be faster, thanks to the fact that you don’t have to go into the other side of the device to disconnect the display. But even if you’ve got the special fixtures Apple uses in their manual, all that adhesive replacement will be delicate, finicky work.

!Image 6: iPhone Duo laid out on a table

_Replacing that inner screen will cost half as much as a whole new device._

Why Are Some of the Pixels Oval?

Zooming past the nano-texture down to the subpixels, we think we’ve found another clue to how Apple hides the crease. Some of the red, green, and blue pixels are oval, with their long axes pointing in different directions.

Oval subpixels have been around for years: DisplayMate photographed them in Samsung’s Galaxy S4 in 2013. But Samsung’s oval pixels are arranged regularly. The Duo pixels are more, uh, wobbly. Weird!

!Image 7

_A nerd snipe for all you pattern-matchers: Can you figure out what the pixel pattern is here before you read on?_

So we went to the patents for an explanation: An Apple patent application on reducing diffraction artifacts describes varying subpixel shapes and orientations to make reflected light produce less conspicuous patterns. It’s a kind of geometric dithering, changing the repeating pattern so its optical artifacts don’t all reinforce one another.

One figure from the patent explains why it’s so hard to figure out the pattern of pixel orientation from our microscope shots. The display is divided into regions that each have their own pattern. Through rotations within and across the regions, each subpixel may have, Apple says, “at least 32 unique displacements.”

!Image 8

A 2025 Apple patent, Mitigation of Diffraction Artifacts in Polarizer-Free Displays, suggests there’s a method in the pixel madness.

That could be another piece of the crease-hiding puzzle, taming reflections deeper in the display that might otherwise draw your eye to the fold.

How Apple Controls the Bend

Every manufacturer is trying to ease the strain on the screen so the crease doesn’t get any deeper, and the design of the hinge is the starting quarterback.

The Duo hinge has a whole playbook here, starting with how it makes room for the bend. The Motorola Razr we tore down in 2020 already tucked its flexible screen into a curved space inside the hinge, and basically every foldable since has adopted its waterdrop approach. The Duo does something similar.

!Image 9: 3D model of the iPhone Duo screen folding in a teardrop shape

Our 3D model shows the Duo in its fully folded state. Though the phone folds flat, the screen is gently curved inside the hinge.

Apple also uses gears, springs, and a series of metal joints to control the bend. Their hinge patent describes linked joints that each rotate through a limited range, kind of like a metal watchband.

!Image 10: iPhone Duo, shell cleaned out Curved guides inside the hinge let those joints move as though their pivot points were inside the screen above them. The goal is to bend the display while reducing how much it gets stretched or squeezed.

!Image 11: Cleaned out iPhone Duo shell

A chain of metal joints share the work of folding.

Springs offset some of the force needed to bend the screen, helping the hinge stay where you leave it.

!Image 12: Springs in the hinge!Image 13: Cleaned out iPhone Duo shell

The Duo isn’t the first foldable to hold a variety of positions, but its system of springs and gears does so quite effectively, even when we strip it down to its bones.

A series of synchronization gears inside the hinge keep the linked joints moving together as you fold the phone. Google chose a different arrangement for the Pixel 10 Pro Fold, replacing synchronization gears with linked, spring-loaded cams, to save space and avoid failures from damaged gear teeth. But gears are predictable. They’re also controllable: Apple’s hinge patent explains how different gear ratios could allow some joints to bend farther than others, letting product designers tighten the curve in one place and leave it gentler elsewhere.

!Image 14: iPhone Duo screen layers

A few of the ten ultrathin layers of the display, peeled away.

Apple describes more than ten ultrathin layers and adhesives that let them glide as the screen folds.

!Image 15: Top shiny part of the inner screen

A closer look at the upper shiny display layer in the picture above. Maybe this is what the display patent describes as a “black matrix” to reduce ambient light reflections?

You’ve undoubtedly experienced a low tech version of this. Bend a stack of paper and the outer pages travel farther than the inner ones. The Duo’s display layers need that same freedom to move, along with enough support to withstand a fingertip pressing on the open screen.

!Image 16: Bottom part of peeled inner screen

A closer look at the display layer under the possible black matrix. These are color filters, tiny colored windows aligned over each subpixel, letting that color through and absorbing the others.

!Image 17: Accordion cable going through the hinge

A gap in the hinge makes way for a thin but mighty accordion-pleated cable that passes both data and power.

The cable joining the two halves is folded into accordion-like pleats that help it accommodate the phone’s movement. That thin little cable has a lot of responsibility. The Duo only has charging infrastructure on one side, so one battery charges through this flex cable. It also has to pass a lot of video and audio data across the gap.

What We Know About Those Broken Screens

Okay, so could that accordion cable be responsible for the damage that people are seeing to their Duo screens? The cable between the halves of a foldable is always under suspicion for damage, and rightly so. But in this case, the symptoms point in another direction.

People describe opening or closing their device, hearing a noise, and then seeing a small line extending down the fold and a bright line extending across the display. One owner had this happen within six hours of buying the phone, another before they’d even finished setup.

!Image 18

Image from Reddit user leftyhyzer16, who says, “Maybe folded it 4 times, hinge got tight and then made a loud pop when I pushed past it.”

Others have collected photos of similar damage across several devices, with more reports and discussion on the MacRumors forums.

We know the damage probably isn’t as big as the footprint. Some affected users say they can’t even see any other problems with their screen or hinge with the naked eye, and that’s not too surprising. A localized fault in the tiny electrical connections can affect an entire row or column of pixels.

To see where the stresses build up from folding, we built a 3D hinge model from teardown footage, patents, and CT scans, then compared it with the reported damage locations. The breaks cluster near the transition from the gap for the crossing flex cable to the central hinge support. The damage we’re seeing in photos isn’t right where the display cable passes through the hinge, but slightly lower, at a point where several edges meet and change how the thin display is supported as it bends.

!Image 19

Here’s one of the broken screens, with our CT and hinge model overlaid. White lines crossing the right side of the display and running down along the hinge show the row and column of damaged pixels. They intersect just below where the display cable passes through the center of the hinge.

All those edges meeting in this spot mean lots of possible culprits. That center pivot looks different from the rest of the hinge. Could it be getting stuck? Could something else be getting stuck?

Here’s one possible answer. In our closing simulation below, the center support bar fails to drop far enough. The screen’s curved fold comes down onto it, creating a small stress hotspot near the reported break location.

Video 6

Want to explore some hypotheses yourself? Check out our interactive CT scan below, courtesy of our beloved Lumafield Neptune scanner, to see how the hinge supports, cable, and nearby components fit beneath the display.

The Hinge Still Crunches

We’ve been following glowing dust through foldables for years, most recently in our Galaxy Z Fold8 and Pixel 11 Pro Fold teardowns.

!Image 20: Dust glowing in the iPhone Duo USB port and speakers

The USB-C port and speaker grilles have a nice coating of glow dust.

The powder is finer than typical beach sand, but when we compared it to office dirt, we saw lots of similar-sized particles. The glow lets us track where those particles end up. To be clear, this isn’t an IP test; IP certifications measure ingress of water and particles into the device’s “enclosure,” which doesn’t seem to include the hinge mechanism of a foldable.

We put the Duo in a bag of fluorescent powder, worked it open and closed, then took it apart to follow the glow. The hinge started crunching.

!Image 21: Dust glowing around the iPhone Duo's camera assembly Most of the powder stopped at the adhesive barriers around the electronics.

We found traces around openings, mesh, and trim, and some reached the moving parts of the hinge.

!Image 22: Glow dust around the iPhone Duo display

The glow gathers around the inner screen’s perimeter.

Where’d the dust go? Check it out for yourself with these natural light vs. UV light comparison sliders:

The Duo collected less visible powder than in our previous Fold8 and Pixel 11 Pro Fold tests, but enough reached the hinge to make it crunch. Cleaning or replacing those moving parts means removing the flexible display and its supports.

We hoped Apple would solve this problem, but sadly it seems like the Duo’s got the same sand-phobia as its folding cousins.

The Trim Comes Off in One Piece

The Duo wins easily over most other foldables in at least one category: the trim. The trim around the Galaxy Z Fold8’s inner screen crumbled as we removed it. We had another broken part to deal with before we’d even reached the panel.

The Duo’s inner-display trim by contrast was a relief. Following Apple’s procedure, we worked it free with a spudger and released the clips. The trim came off intact.

!Image 23

The outer display also came off intact, including the plastic frame that gave us so much grief during our iPhone 18 Pro teardown. That’s important because several internal repairs require going through it, and nobody wants a battery repair to become a screen repair, too.

!Image 24: Front screen coming off the iPhone Duo Clips and screws hold the outer display and back cover alongside their adhesive seals. In a pinch, those fasteners let you put the phone back together while you wait for fresh adhesive (minus water resistance, of course).

Familiar iPhone Repair Tricks

We’ve wondered during many iPhone teardowns of yore: could Apple be testing out a strategy for their foldable debut? And sure enough, there’s a lot in here that’s familiar.

There are pentalobe screws at the entrance, of course. We’re not fans, ICYMI.

!Image 25: iPhone Duo, pentalobe screws

You know it’s an iPhone when there are pentalobe screws. You know it’s a super iPhone when there are four instead of two.

Then there are the two batteries. Now this part of the repair experience we can get behind. Apple brought its electrically releasable adhesive to both cells, and it works beautifully. Apply power to the release tabs with our VoltClip and FixHub or a 9V battery, wait, and the adhesive lets go.

!Image 26: iPhone Duo batteries with VoltClips

Apple must’ve heard we like hot-wiring batteries.

The cells come out without the alarming bending and prying that can turn a routine repair into a puncture risk.

!Image 27: iPhone Duo, batteries lifted Metal battery shells make for a nice insurance policy, too. If the electrical debonding fails and you have to resort to solvents and prying, the metal protects against an accidental puncture, meaning you’re way less likely to start a fire.

![Image 28: iPhone Duo batteries, front side](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/24232240/iPhone-Duo_176a.jpg)![Image 29: iPhone Duo batteries, backside](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/24232242/iPhone-Duo_176b.jpg)

Both batteries come out cleanly, with minimal adhesive residue. The left battery in the image has 7.5 Wh; the right battery has 11.6 Wh for a total of 19.1 Wh.

We’ve explained the underlying process in our guide to electrically debonding iPhone battery adhesive with our VoltClip.

Featured Guide

How to Use the VoltClip to Debond iPhone Battery Adhesive

This guide demonstrates how to use iFixit’s…

Follow this Guide

![Image 30: How to Use the VoltClip to Debond iPhone Battery Adhesive](https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/How+to+Use+the+VoltClip+to+Debond+iPhone+Battery+Adhesive/177712)

The Duo uses the same basic technology as previous phones, but each battery has two separate strips, each of which has its own set of tabs.

It’s the best battery-removal experience we’ve seen in a foldable so far. Seriously. Two years in, and we still love this electrically released adhesive. We’re champing at the bit to see it in display adhesive, too.

Gotta Love a Flat Disassembly Tree

The internal layout is fairly flat, so cameras and charging hardware are accessible with little additional disassembly.

!Image 31: iPhone Duo camera assembly

An interesting little bracket that sits over the main camera assembly.

That’s the kind of flatness we like. When we score smartphone repairability, we map the parts you have to remove to reach the one you need. This is called the disassembly tree. A flatter tree means fewer detours, less labor, and fewer opportunities to break something else along the way. We liked this about the iPhone Air, too, and we’re really glad to see the Duo’s borrowed its flat-tree strategy.

!Image 32: Nanotexture and camera cutout, White circles are holes for the under-screen camera to look through

Lit screen with nano-texture layer intact, showing the normal pixel grid on the right and the gaps in the pixel pattern on the left to allow the selfie cam to see through. The big white dots are reflections of selfie cam hardware.

And the inner screen camera is hidden with basically the same method we saw Apple using for the under-display infrared camera in the iPhone 18 Pro. Gaps in the pixel pattern allow the selfie camera to peek through.

!Image 33: Lit screen with nanotexture removed showing the pixel shape change

Lit screen with nano-texture removed.

It works… sort of. Reviewers say its photos are muddy, and lots of people say they’ll skip this camera in favor of the other ones on the phone.

!Image 34: Screen hole punch for the under-screen camera, from the underside

The screen hole punch for the under-screen camera, from the underside.

Luckily, there are three other more-capable cameras in the phone: in addition to the inner selfie camera, there’s a 48 MP f/1.6 main camera, a 48 MP f/2.2 ultrawide, and a 12 MP f/2.2 outer-screen selfie camera (which doesn’t have to peek through the pixel blinds).

!Image 35: iPhone Duo camera assembly

The main camera assembly’s hardware sits near the surface, with brackets and connectors to clear. And screws. A lot of them.

Speaking of flat, the Duo’s outer selfie camera is incredibly thin.

!Image 36: iPhone Duo camera assemblies

The three camera modules, featuring four cameras, seen edge-on. From left to right: a pair of rear cameras, an inner selfie camera, and an outer-screen selfie camera.

The logic board is also unusually flat: almost every iPhone since the iPhone 8 (except, e.g., XR and SE) has had a double-layer logic board. Here, it’s unstacked. Instead of a board sandwich, we have a single layer logic board with some functionality outsourced to the single layer I/O board.

![Image 37: iPhone Duo daughter board](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/24232231/iPhone-Duo_100.jpg)![Image 38: iPhone Duo daughter board](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/24232229/iPhone-Duo_99.jpg)![Image 39: iPhone Duo logic board](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/24232228/iPhone-Duo_98.jpg)![Image 40: iPhone Duo logic board](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/24232226/iPhone-Duo_97.jpg)

Above: Single layer I/O board, both sides. Below: Single layer logic board, both sides.

Now, though this disassembly tree’s pretty flat, it could be flatter. Some components are still buried under flex cables. We also needed five different screwdriver types to finish the teardown. Requiring lots of tool changes slows down repair and increases the chances a would-be repairer will get thwarted by insufficient tools (but not you, though, right? Because you’ve got a Pro Tech Toolkit, right?).

![Image 41](https://www.ifixit.com/products/pro-tech-toolkit)

**Never have insufficient tools again.**

You’re a repairer, not a would-be repairer.

!Image 42: iPhone Duo laid out on a table

A Provisional 5/10 for Repairability

The iPhone Duo earns a provisional 5 out of 10 for repairability, the highest score we’ve given a foldable smartphone so far.

!Image 43: Provisional repairability score of 5 out of 10

The outer screen survived removal, the batteries released cleanly, and smaller components are fairly accessible. Apple has already published its repair manual. Our score’s provisional because we’re still waiting on replacement parts, though we expect them to arrive through Apple’s self-service program soon.

The inner display and hinge account for the biggest deduction. Replacing them takes a lot of work, and the price could put owners off repairing the phone at all. Many are opting for Apple Care+ coverage for this reason (great if you don’t mind yet another monthly subscription fee). The early reports of screen failures make clear that display replacement is more than a distant possibility.

If you’re looking for a repairable smartphone, we’d still recommend a conventional phone (did you see we gave the latest Fairphone another well-deserved 10/10?).

For a first attempt, Apple has done well. The easy battery removal alone is something we’d like to see on every foldable. But of course we’ll hold Apple accountable for making replacement parts available, and here’s hoping that the next generation of the Duo features a more affordable inner display and a more accessible hinge repair.

You’d better baby that screen, Duo owners. And maybe quit carrying around that pocket sand.

!Image 44: Closeup of a sensor cutout from the underside of the screen

One bonus microscope shot, because it’s too cool-looking to leave out. Closeup of a sensor cutout from the underside of the screen.

Wallpapers

We’ve made these wallpapers from our CT scans in pairs, for the front and inside screens.

To set them:

1. Click to open each image in a new tab, then long press to save the images to your Photos app. 2. Open the Settings app on your iPhone and tap Wallpaper. 3. Swipe left or right to find the wallpaper setup you want to change, then tap Customize under the left screen (Lock Screen) preview. 4. Tap the Photos icon (bottom left) to select and apply your first website image, then tap Done in the top right. 5. Next, tap Customize under the right screen (Home Screen) preview. 6. Tap Photo (at the bottom) to select your second website image. 7. Turn off Blur: Tap the Blur button in the bottom right corner so it is unhighlighted (otherwise, your second image will look blurry). 8. Tap Done in the top right corner to save your changes.

![Image 45](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25213050/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-2-Inner.jpg)

v2 Inner

![Image 46](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25213052/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-2-Outer.jpg)

v2 Outer

![Image 47](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25213055/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-3-Inner.jpg)

v3 Inner

![Image 48](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25213109/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-3-Outer.jpg)

v3 Outer

![Image 49](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25213105/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-4-Inner.jpg)

v4 Inner

![Image 50](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25213103/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-4-Outer.jpg)

v4 Outer

![Image 51](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25213057/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-5-Inner.jpg)

v5 Inner

![Image 52](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25213047/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-5-Outer.jpg)

v5 Outer

![Image 53](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25213101/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-6-Inner.jpg)

v6 Inner

![Image 54](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25213107/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-6-Outer.jpg)

v6 Outer

![Image 55](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25215535/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-7-Inner.jpg)

v7 Inner

![Image 56](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25215530/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-7-Outer.jpg)

v7 Outer

![Image 57](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25215541/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-8-Inner.jpg)

v8 Inner

![Image 58](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25215532/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-8-Outer.jpg)

v8 Outer

![Image 59](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25215544/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-9-Inner.jpg)

v9 Inner

![Image 60](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25215547/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-9-Outer.jpg)

v9 Outer

![Image 61](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25215537/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-10-Inner.jpg)

v10 Inner

![Image 62](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25215545/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-10-Outer.jpg)

v10 Outer

![Image 63](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25215528/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-11-Inner.jpg)

v11 Inner

![Image 64](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25215539/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-11-Outer.jpg)

v11 Outer

![Image 65](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25215524/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-12-Inner.jpg)

v12 Inner

![Image 66](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25215521/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-12-Outer.jpg)

v12 Outer

![Image 67](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25215520/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-13-Inner.jpg)

v13 Inner

![Image 68](https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2026/10/25215526/iPhone-Duo-Wallpaper-13-Outer.jpg)

v13 Outer